2A-F: Ebenezer Guthrie

Illustrated family name plates for the children of John Guthrie and Abigail Coe.

Guthrie Family Group 2A · Branch F · Child Page

Ebenezer Guthrie & Hannah Richards

Ebenezer: 1740–1825 · Hannah: 1736–1792
Second wife: Sarah Nichols Hawley, about 1744–1838

Durham · Woodbury · Southbury, Connecticut

The youngest son of John Guthrie and Abigail Coe, Ebenezer inherited land and livestock before establishing his own family with Hannah Richards. He later served Southbury as a selectman and first selectman. Following Hannah’s death, he married Sarah Nichols Hawley.

His 1811 will provides a close view of the household: Sarah’s possessions and support, a river meadow and money for daughter Lois, and the remaining estate for son Obadiah. These records anchor the family while leaving a proposed third child, William, unresolved.

Explore the Research Tree →

Branch F Family Hub · GFG2A Hub · DNA Participation

Family at a Glance

Ebenezer Guthrie

Parents
John Guthrie and Abigail Coe. The Durham transcription names John and Abigail. John’s will calls Ebenezer his youngest son.
Birth & baptism
1740, Durham, Connecticut. Barbour prints birth on 29 July and baptism on 20 July. The Research Tree instead gives birth on 20 July and baptism on 28 July. The exact dates require the original records.
First marriage
16 March 1767, Woodbury, to Hannah Richards, as reported in the family research.
Second marriage
About 1794, to Sarah Nichols Hawley. The original marriage record remains wanted.
Public service
Southbury selectman in 1789–1791 and first selectman in 1792, according to the supplied town-history citations.
Will & death
Will dated 11 December 1811; death recorded as 10 September 1825; will proved 27 September 1825.
Burial
White Oak Cemetery, Southbury. The death index uses the title Captain and gives age 84, which differs from an age calculated from the reported 1740 birth.

Hannah Richards

Birth
30 April 1736, Waterbury, Connecticut, reported in the Research Tree and family study.
Parents
The family study identifies Obadiah Richards and Sarah Ashley. Their relationship should be supported with the original birth and probate records.
Marriage
16 March 1767, to Ebenezer Guthrie.
Children
Lois and Obadiah Richards Guthrie are confirmed as Ebenezer’s children by his will. William is an additional family-history attribution requiring proof. The will does not name their mother.
Death
30 June 1792 in the Research Tree and the family study’s summary. A narrative passage instead gives 30 July. June is retained provisionally pending comparison with the underlying record.
Burial
White Oak Cemetery, Southbury, reported in the family research.

Second Wife: Sarah Nichols Hawley

About 1744–3 July 1838. The family history supplies the name Sarah Nichols Hawley; her parentage, birthplace, and the relationship between those surnames remain to be established. The name alone is not proof of a particular maiden surname or earlier marriage.

Sarah reportedly married Ebenezer about 1794. No children are recorded for this marriage. His will names her as his wife and refers to an agreement made before their marriage. She survived him and is reported buried with him and Hannah at White Oak Cemetery, Southbury.

The Children

Two children confirmed in Ebenezer’s will; one additional proposed child. Lois and Obadiah are retained as the established children in the family reconstruction. William remains visible as an unresolved attribution, not a confirmed third child.

Child Dates Family & evidence
Lois Guthrie 23 December 1767–5 October 1834 Married Moses Asa Johnson, 19 November 1787. Named daughter Lois Johnson in the 1811 will.
Obadiah Richards Guthrie 1 April 1769–27 November 1842 Married Beersheba Howe, 1 March 1797. Named son, residuary beneficiary, and executor in the will. Autosomal participant line.
William Guthrie — proposed Birth and death unestablished Attributed by American Guthrie and Allied Families; absent from the reviewed will. Possible confusion with grandson William Guthrie, 1800–1865.
Lois Guthrie & Moses Asa Johnson

Lois’s birth is reported as 23 December 1767 at Southbury. She married Moses Asa Johnson on 19 November 1787. The family study identifies him as a son of Asa Johnson and Elizabeth Strong and grandson of Moses Johnson and Prudence Jenner; these connections remain attributed to that study pending record comparison.

Ebenezer’s will calls her Lois Johnson. In addition to earlier gifts, it provides the part of his river meadow on the west side of the river and £200 lawful money, payable from the specified lot bought from Col. Kellerton at the appraised value, with any balance from his personal estate.

Moses reportedly died in 1821; Lois died 5 October 1834, aged sixty-six. Their burial is reported at White Oak Cemetery. Her name may recall Hannah’s sister Lois Richards, but that naming explanation is an inference.

  1. Ebenezer Johnson, 3 March 1791–1 April 1872; married Sally Mitchell; children.
  2. Asa Johnson, 29 March 1793–1 November 1850; marriage not established.
  3. Hannah Johnson, 28 March 1794–17 February 1867; married William Fabrique; children.
  4. Thomas Johnson, 8 March 1798–26 March 1834; married Maria P. Moseley in 1827; children.
Obadiah Richards Guthrie & Beersheba Howe

Obadiah was born 1 April 1769 at Southbury and married Beersheba Howe on 1 March 1797. The family study describes him as a farmer. His name recalls Hannah’s reported father, Obadiah Richards.

He served as a Southbury selectman in 1807 and first selectman in 1808–1810, according to the Research Tree’s town-history notes. His father’s will gives him the residue of the real and personal estate and appoints him executor. On 27 September 1825, Obadiah R. Guthrie and Albert Guthrie signed a $3,000 executor’s bond. That sum is the bond’s penalty, not an appraisal of the estate.

Obadiah died 27 November 1842 and is reported buried in South Britain Burying Ground. Beersheba died 18 August 1853, reportedly aged seventy-seven. The seven children retained from the tree and family study are:

  1. Sally Guthrie, 1797–1842 Connecticut; reported unmarried.
  2. William Guthrie, 1800–1865 Connecticut; lawyer; married Polly Ann Tuttle in 1842; children. He must be kept distinct from the proposed son William attributed to Ebenezer and Hannah.
  3. Albert Guthrie, 1802–1888; married Nancy Buckingham in 1825; children. The Albert named on Ebenezer’s executor’s bond is consistent with this family, although the bond itself does not state the relationship.
  4. Ebenezer Guthrie, 1804–1881 Connecticut; married Harriet Edmonds in 1827; children. The Research Tree marks this descendant line for autosomal participation.
  5. Hannah Guthrie, 1807–1864 Connecticut; married Roderick Stiles in 1861, then Ira Bradley in 1863. Ira had previously married her sister Ann.
  6. Ann Guthrie, 1811–1860 Connecticut; married Ira Bradley in 1836; children.
  7. John Benjamin Guthrie, 1813–1889; married Eva Downs; children.
William Guthrie: an unresolved child attribution

American Guthrie and Allied Families credits Ebenezer and Hannah with a son William, without the life details needed to identify him securely. Records of the Guthrie Family, as discussed in the family study, lists Lois and Obadiah only.

William is not named in the will dated 11 December 1811. His omission does not establish his death before either 1811 or the 1825 probate. The tree’s 1825 death endpoint is therefore not treated as a documented death date.

One possibility is confusion with William Guthrie, 1800–1865, son of Obadiah and Beersheba. That is a research question, not a resolved identity. A birth, baptism, guardianship, deed, or estate document explicitly connecting another William to Ebenezer is needed.

↑ Return to Menu

Explore the Records

The original will and its probate papers establish relationships that the compiled histories can only describe retrospectively. The record summaries below keep those sources separate from indexes, family traditions, and unresolved identifications.

Birth, baptism, marriages & cemetery evidence
  • Durham Barbour transcription, page 45: Ebenezer, son of John and Abigail, baptized 20 July 1740, citing original page 278; born 29 July 1740, citing page 359. The baptism precedes the stated birth. The original entries are needed; the dates should not simply be exchanged to make them fit.
  • Research Tree and family study: give birth 20 July and baptism 28 July 1740, and attribute the baptism to Rev. Nathaniel Chauncy. These differ from the photographed Barbour page.
  • Hannah Richards: reported birth 30 April 1736 at Waterbury and marriage 16 March 1767 at Woodbury. Compare the underlying Barbour entries and the Richards probate before treating the reported parentage as proved.
  • Hannah’s death: 30 June 1792 in the tree and family summary; 30 July in a narrative passage. The cemetery or death record should settle the month.
  • Connecticut Deaths and Burials Index, film 3362: Captain Ebenezer Guthrie, died 10 September 1825, aged 84, buried at Southbury. The calculated birth estimate of about 1741 is derived from that age, not a separate birth record.
  • Find a Grave index: White Oak Cemetery; gives Ebenezer’s birth as 29 July 1740 and death as 10 September 1825. Compare the actual marker and Hale cemetery copy; an index is not an independent witness to every linked relationship.
  • Sarah Nichols Hawley: name and approximate 1794 marriage come from the family history. Her original marriage record, premarital agreement, and 1838 estate may clarify her earlier identity.
Ebenezer’s will and estate: Woodbury packet 1768

Woodbury Probate District, estate of Ebenezer Guthrie of Southbury, 1825, packet 1768. The supplied images cover the packet at viewer images 897–902, within “Probate Packets, Gillett, M–Hannah, H, 1720–1880.” The cover lists one will and one bond.

  • 11 December 1811: will dated at Southbury. Names wife Sarah, daughter Lois Johnson, and son Obadiah Richards Guthrie.
  • Sarah: receives her brought-in possessions or replacements, one-third of the personal estate, specified use of the house and lot during widowhood, and additional support provisions. The will refers to a premarital agreement.
  • Lois: receives the west-side portion of the river meadow and £200 lawful money, in addition to earlier gifts.
  • Obadiah: receives the residue of the real and personal estate and is appointed executor.
  • 27 September 1825: witness attestation and probate endorsement. The witnesses affirm the testator’s execution of the will and capacity at that time.
  • 27 September 1825: executor’s bond signed by Obadiah R. Guthrie and Albert Guthrie, with a $3,000 penalty.

The will does not name William. It also does not state the children’s mother, establish Sarah’s maiden name, or give Ebenezer’s exact death date. Those questions require other records.

Census households: 1790, 1800, 1810 & the misplaced 1830 entry
Year Indexed household & interpretation
1790 Ebenezer Guthrie, Southbury: four males aged 16 or older and two females. The counts do not identify each resident or prove the presence of a son William.
1800 Indexed as Ebens Guthrie: one male 10–15, one male 45 or older, and one female 45 or older. The younger male’s relationship is unknown.
1810 E Gutry, marked as a possible match in the tree: one male 10–15, one male 16–25, one male 45 or older, one female 16–25, and one female 45 or older. Identification requires the original page and neighborhood comparison.
1830 An Ebenezer Guthrie household has one male 10–14, one male 20–29, one female 10–14, one female 20–29, and one female 80–89. This cannot be a residence record for the Ebenezer who died in 1825.

The younger Ebenezer, born in 1804 to Obadiah and Beersheba, is a candidate for the 1830 head of household. Sarah’s approximate age would also fit the elderly female. Both are hypotheses: the census names only the head and does not establish those identities or relationships.

Town service, military tradition & compiled family accounts
  • Selectmen, Town of Southbury, Connecticut, 1787 through 2010: the supplied citations list Ebenezer as selectman in 1789, 1790, and 1791, and first selectman in 1792. The Research Tree also attributes Obadiah’s 1807–1810 offices to this town history.
  • American Guthrie and Allied Families, page 154: account of Ebenezer, born in 1740, and Hannah Richards. Preserve its military and William-child statements as attributed claims until corroborated.
  • Records of the Guthrie Family: the existing family study cites this work for Lois, Obadiah, and Sarah Nichols Hawley. Its account should be compared with the original marriage and probate documents.
  • Guthrie Genealogy family study and Research Tree: sources for the descendant details and continuing research leads.

Keep the two Ebenezers separate: this page concerns Ebenezer Guthrie, 1740–1825, son of John and Abigail Coe. His nephew Ebenezer, 1770–1855, son of Ephraim and Thankful Stone, married Abigail Herick and later Martha Cowles Ashley. The nephew’s Y-DNA kits do not represent this elder Ebenezer’s descendant line.

Most Wanted Documents
  1. Original Durham birth and baptism entries behind Barbour’s conflicting July 1740 dates.
  2. Marriage records for Hannah Richards in 1767 and Sarah Nichols Hawley about 1794, plus the premarital agreement mentioned in the will.
  3. Hannah’s birth, death, and Richards probate records to confirm parentage and resolve June versus July 1792.
  4. Evidence for the proposed son William: a record explicitly identifying him as Ebenezer’s son, distinct from grandson William, born in 1800.
  5. Military documentation: a commission, muster, payroll, or other original record establishing Ebenezer’s rank and Revolutionary War service.
  6. Sarah’s 1838 estate and the original 1830 census page to investigate her later household and earlier identity.
  7. Documented paternal-line descendants of Obadiah interested in representing this family through Y-DNA testing.

DNA Participation

No Y-DNA or Big-Y representative is currently assigned to Ebenezer Guthrie and Hannah Richards’s line in the reviewed project material. The Research Tree marks Ebenezer as Y-DNA Needed. Branch F’s existing Y-DNA representation through his brothers must not be counted as a test of his own descendant line.

Autosomal participation is recorded through son Obadiah Richards Guthrie. The tree continues the participant marker through Obadiah’s son Ebenezer Guthrie, 1804–1881. The supplied material does not identify the testing platform or a public kit number, so neither is inferred.

Living participant names are omitted. The proposed William line is retained as an unresolved research entry, not counted as a confirmed child line.
Child’s line Y-DNA Big-Y Autosomal DNA
Lois Guthrie Johnson Not applicable through this daughter Not applicable through this daughter Not currently recorded
Obadiah Richards Guthrie Representative sought Not recorded Participant line recorded through son Ebenezer, 1804–1881; platform and public kit not specified.
William Guthrie — proposed No documented descendant line established Not recorded Not recorded; identity unresolved

A documented father-to-son descendant of Obadiah could provide the first Y-DNA representation specifically assigned to this line. Big-Y testing could then help refine its relationship to the other represented Branch F families. Autosomal participation supports collaboration, but its presence alone does not establish an unproved historical relationship.

Help Build the Family Story

Interpretive watercolor of colonial ironworks beside autumn water, shared Branch F artwork.

Ebenezer’s family left a record of town service, household provision, and generations rooted in Southbury. His will brings Sarah, Lois, and Obadiah into clear view, while other questions still depend on records waiting to be compared.

Family Bibles, original church entries, deeds, military papers, cemetery photographs, and documented descendant lines are welcome. Evidence for William, Sarah’s earlier identity, and the conflicting birth and baptism dates would be especially valuable.

Researched & Curated by Ann Guthrie