4-A: Sarah Guthrey

Embroidered Guthrey family tree sampler

Guthrie Family Group 4 · Branch A · Child Page

Sarah “Sally” Guthrey & Benjamin Coleman

Amherst County, Virginia · Corn Creek, Kentucky

View in Guthrie Research Tree →

Sally’s name survives in her own right on an Amherst deed. In September 1804 she and Benjamin sold land on Irish Creek. Twenty years later Benjamin’s Kentucky will provided for his wife Sally and named their eight children. Together those records follow the couple across a move that took different members of the family west at different times.

The Family at a Glance

Sarah “Sally” Guthrey

Birth
10 May 1752 in the family account, probably in Virginia. County of birth remains uncertain.
Marriage
18 February 1771, reported. Neither an original bond nor the county of solemnization has been established.
Death and burial
Buried at Corn Creek. Family sources favor June 1825, with both the 24th and 27th reported. A published reading of her broken marker gives 24 June 1835.

Benjamin Coleman

Birth
3 September 1751, reported. Daniel Coleman and Patience Thompson are proposed parents.
Ministry
Licensed to perform marriages in Amherst in 1782. He served Buffalo Baptist Church. Witnesses to marriages and contemporary church history help identify him.
Death
13 September 1832, reported. Buried at Corn Creek, then in Oldham County. The cemetery is now in Trimble County.

Children of Sarah “Sally” Guthrey & Benjamin Coleman

Benjamin’s will provides for his wife and names the children, including married daughters. Wills of the children help distinguish cousins who shared the same name.

ChildBirthMarriage & Later Life
Daniel Coleman20 September 1772, reportedA Shelby County bond dated 31 December 1797 names Elizabeth Connell. Daniel acquired land on Corn Creek and left a Gallatin County will in 1833.
Sarah “Sally” ColemanAbout 1773Married Peter Gabhart, also recorded as Gabbart or Gabbert. Benjamin’s will identifies his daughter Sally. Check the marriage documents before attaching entries for Sarah Bottom.
Elizabeth ColemanAbout 1775Her father consented to her marriage to John Reed in Amherst in October 1792. Reed also appears as Read or Reid. His pension file is S11280.
Patience ColemanAbout 1784Married John Sandidge Jr. Their reported marriage was 22 January 1803. The couple’s Kentucky records continue into the federal census period.
Virgil Coleman1786, reportedMarried Lydia Limmon in Kentucky and later Mary “Polly” Cummins. His Corn Creek land and his Ripley County, Indiana, probate identify the family.
Mary “Polly” ColemanAbout 1788Married Burdett Mayfield in 1812. Kentucky land records and the Indiana probate records help trace their household.
Wyatt Coleman6 August 1791, reportedMarried Cynthia Connell and then Catharine Nicholson. His Trimble County will is on p. 148 of Will Book 1. The will on pp. 145–146 belongs to his nephew Wyatt F. Coleman.
Lucy Coleman1790s, estimates varyMarried Zachariah McGannon on 22 December 1815 in Henry County, Kentucky. They settled in Jennings County, Indiana. Census ages and memorial dates differ on her birth.
Following the next generation

The Kentucky wills. Daniel’s 1833 Gallatin will identifies his children by name and provides for William’s guardianship. The Trimble will books preserve two Wyatt Colemans. Daniel’s son Wyatt F. named wife Martha. Sarah’s son Wyatt married Cynthia Connell and Catharine Nicholson. The two wills are only a few pages apart.

Families on both sides of the Ohio River. Reed, Sandidge, Gabbert and Coleman records follow the Kentucky households. Virgil’s probate belongs in Ripley County, Indiana. Jennings County records follow Lucy McGannon. Use residence and spouse to distinguish these families when later documents repeat names such as Wyatt and Sarah.

Guthrie DNA Project Participation

Child lineY-DNABig YAutosomal
DanielN/AN/A—
SarahN/AN/A—
ElizabethN/AN/A—
PatienceN/AN/A—
VirgilN/AN/A—
MaryN/AN/A—
WyattN/AN/A—
LucyN/AN/A—

✓ marks a documented autosomal line. A dash marks a category without an assigned result in this review. N/A marks a child through whom the Guthrey Y chromosome did not pass.

Historical Highlights

An open Bible with Virginia land records

Amherst ministerial records put Benjamin at marriages he conducted. A widow’s pension testimony recalls him officiating in 1786. Sally and Benjamin signed the 1804 sale of 104 acres. Benjamin’s 1806 deed describes a separate tract on Shady Mountain Creek. The two instruments give different details about the family’s connection to Virginia after some of their children had reached Kentucky.

Family Timeline

  1. 1771Reported marriage of Sally Guthrey and Benjamin Coleman.
  2. 1782Amherst licensed Benjamin to perform marriages.
  3. 1792–97Benjamin consented to Elizabeth’s marriage in Virginia. Daniel’s marriage bond places him in Kentucky by the end of 1797.
  4. 1804–06The Colemans conveyed two Amherst tracts, one on Irish Creek and one on Shady Mountain Creek.
  5. 1824Benjamin signed his will on 11 September, naming Sally and all eight children.
  6. 1832Benjamin died in September. His Oldham County probate includes a will, inventory and sale account.
Corn Creek and the move west

Sources associate both Benjamin Coleman and John Taylor with the beginnings of Corn Creek Baptist Church. Its minutes offer a way to distinguish a founding member, a visiting preacher and a regular pastor. The 1810 Henry County census has an age discrepancy for the proposed Benjamin household. County boundaries and adult children already in Kentucky complicate the migration date.

Explore the Research

DNA & the Family Line

Descendants of Sally’s children can contribute autosomal evidence. The branch review lists no represented child line through Sally. Benjamin’s sons inherited his Coleman paternal line. Guthrey Y-DNA comparisons for Thomas’s family come through his sons.

What the war records establish

Virginia’s public service claims document Benjamin furnishing supplies. DAR identifies this patriot as A206054. Pension W6615 is the file of Henry Campbell, whose widow recalled that Benjamin had married them. A later cemetery marker assigns Benjamin a North Carolina captaincy. Establish the captain’s home, unit and associates independently before treating the two men as one.

Sally’s date of death

The tree gives 27 June 1825, while a memorial gives 24 June 1825. The legacy transcription of the broken stone reads 24 June 1835 and says she was in her seventy-third year. The age is closer to 1825 if the reported 1752 birth is correct. Benjamin’s 1824 will places her alive then. The 1830 household does not identify her by name. A dated photograph or early inscription transcript could resolve the year.

Nancy in Benjamin’s will

Benjamin directed that Nancy, an enslaved woman, pass to his daughter Sally. He left the remaining estate for his wife’s support during her life. The probate inventory and sale account may show what happened to Nancy after his death. The wife and the daughter are both called Sally in these papers.

Reading & Sources

Start with these records

The collections below include records for relatives, neighbors and people with similar names. A link to an index is a finding aid. Identifications depend on the underlying entry. Some images require a sign-in or access through a participating library.

Family, ministry, Virginia land and Corn Creek
The children’s Kentucky and Indiana land and estates
Mayfield and Wyatt Coleman probate
Amherst marriage records and deeds · earlier books
Amherst deeds · later books
Church histories, Amherst tax records and county studies
Harrison, Henry, Oldham and Trimble land records
Revolutionary service and competing military identifications
Oldham probate, including Benjamin’s will and estate
Gallatin County grantor index and deeds
Gallatin County grantee index and deeds
Additional published sources and probate indexes
Most Wanted Documents
  • Locate a Coleman–Guthrey bond or contemporary marriage entry identifying the 1771 county.
  • Obtain the earliest readable Corn Creek inscription or photograph showing both the year and Sally’s age.
  • Compare the Oldham will, inventory and sale papers to trace Nancy. Check the early church minutes for Benjamin’s role at Corn Creek.

Continue the Family’s Story

A family Bible beside an open farmhouse door

The Irish Creek deed puts Sally’s own name beside Benjamin’s. A surviving church minute, cemetery reading or Coleman family Bible might tell us when she joined her children in Kentucky and when the family buried her at Corn Creek.

Researched & Curated by Ann Guthrie

Leave a Reply